| 订阅 | 在线投稿
分享
 
 
 

几个库DGL、STL(vc6)、STL(SGI)、DCL 、DeCal 、EZDSL的容器性能对比测试

来源:互联网网民  宽屏版  评论
2006-12-05 19:16:31

(Delphi泛型库DGL 下载)

几个库DGL、STL(vc6)、STL(SGI)、DCL 、DeCal、EZDSL的容器性能对比测试

(2006.10.20 DGL Profiler

DGL添加红黑树,增加容器:_TMap\_TMultiMap\_TSet\_TMultiSet;

更新DeCal和EZDSL的Hash表测试,由于它们不支持动态调整大小所以造成以前的测试成绩不能反映真实情况;

测试Visite或Find的时候会同时测试读和写,如果不能写,就读两次

DGL和STL使用了相同的测试,测试数据集1000万个integer;选用integer能够更好地反映库的性能;

(某些Delphi库使用string的测试成绩来说自己的库比STL的快完全是误导,这完全是由string的不同实现导致的);

其他几个库的测试,如果库的性能比较差,就会采取减小测试数据集的办法来减少测试时间;

对于线性容器(vector\deque\list)的随机访问使用了1M个integer;

)

CPU: AMD Athlon(tm)64 3000+(1.81G)

DGL lib (Delphi7 Compile)========================================================

Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront

TVector 0.011 us 0.008 us 0.086 us 31400.000 us 75000.000 us

TDeque 0.009 us 0.012 us 0.219 us 100000.000 us 0.009 us

TList 0.048 us 0.017 us 8590.000 us 0.077 us 0.055 us

IVector 0.018 us 0.018 us 0.110 us 31200.000 us 75000.000 us

IDeque 0.014 us 0.019 us 0.235 us 103200.000 us 0.011 us

IList 0.073 us 0.022 us 8440.000 us 0.077 us 0.056 us

Container: Insert Find Next Visite

Map 0.384 us 3.383 us 0.070 us

MultiMap 0.388 us 3.706 us 0.097 us

Set 0.461 us 3.253 us 0.064 us

MultiSet 0.457 us 3.260 us 0.064 us

HashMap 0.288 us 0.857 us 0.048 us

HashMultiMap 0.296 us 0.961 us 0.067 us

HashSet 0.284 us 0.869 us 0.052 us

HashMultiSet 0.254 us 0.868 us 0.046 us

DGL lib (Turbo Delphi2006 Compile)========================================================

Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront

TVector 0.029 us 0.007 us 0.079 us 27600.000 us 66800.000 us

TDeque 0.007 us 0.009 us 0.234 us 113200.000 us 0.006 us

TList 0.029 us 0.015 us 8520.000 us 0.066 us 0.037 us

IVector 0.025 us 0.015 us 0.107 us 33000.000 us 79600.000 us

IDeque 0.010 us 0.015 us 0.245 us 103400.000 us 0.013 us

IList 0.050 us 0.017 us 8950.000 us 0.054 us 0.034 us

Container: Insert Find Next Visite

Map 0.370 us 3.592 us 0.075 us

MultiMap 0.388 us 3.873 us 0.104 us

Set 0.366 us 3.254 us 0.062 us

MultiSet 0.345 us 3.275 us 0.062 us

HashMap 0.292 us 0.832 us 0.039 us

HashMultiMap 0.275 us 0.898 us 0.060 us

HashSet 0.248 us 0.847 us 0.043 us

HashMultiSet 0.245 us 0.847 us 0.036 us

================================================================================

Delphi7=========================================================================

Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront

array 0.170 us 0.005 us 0.078 us 43800.000 us 121800.000 us

TList 0.023 us 0.013 us 0.125 us 25000.000 us 62400.000 us

================================================================================

STL (VC6 Compile)===============================================================

Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront

vector 0.041 us 0.005 us 0.078 us 31200 us 68800 us

deque 0.013 us 0.006 us 0.227 us 365600 us 0.012 us

list 0.169 us 0.022 us 21800 us 0.180 us 0.183 us

Container: Insert Find Next Visite

map 0.431 us 3.174 us 0.048 us

set 0.433 us 3.174 us 0.049 us

multimap 0.430 us 3.174 us 0.047 us

multiset 0.427 us 3.174 us 0.048 us

STL (VC2005 Compile)===============================================================

vector 0.019 us 0.009 us 0.078 us 62600 us 140600 us

deque 0.067 us 0.013 us 0.227 us 168800 us 0.061 us

list 0.269 us 0.017 us 15600 us 0.277 us 0.269 us

Container: Insert Find Next Visite

map 2.436 us 4.813 us 0.042 us

set 2.473 us 4.813 us 0.041 us

multimap 2.420 us 4.813 us 0.041 us

multiset 2.416 us 4.813 us 0.041 us

hash_map 0.888 us 1.501 us 0.207 us

hash_set 1.378 us 1.453 us 0.207 us

hash_multimap 1.373 us 1.450 us 0.207 us

hash_multiset 1.380 us 1.450 us 0.207 us

(SGI)STL (DEV-C++4.98 GCC max optimize Compile)=================================

Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront

vector 0.016 us 0.005 us 0.070 us 34400 us 62400 us

deque 0.011 us 0.009 us 0.258 us 865600 us 0.013 us

list 0.047 us 0.014 us 9400 us 0.052 us 0.036 us

Container: Insert Find Next Visite

map 0.538 us 3.226 us 0.033 us

set 0.516 us 3.226 us 0.034 us

multimap 0.492 us 3.174 us 0.038 us

multiset 0.495 us 3.994 us 0.039 us

hash_map 0.145 us 0.701 us 0.043 us

hash_set 0.234 us 0.650 us 0.044 us

hash_multimap 0.639 us 0.698 us 0.044 us

hash_multiset 0.138 us 0.650 us 0.043 us

================================================================================

DCL lib (Delphi7 Compile)=======================================================

Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront

TArrayList 0.013 us 0.030 us 0.157 us 25000.000 us 65600.000 us

TVector 0.013 us 0.027 us 0.172 us 28200.000 us 62600.000 us

TLinkedList 0.045 us 0.023 us 5780.000 us 0.052 us 0.081 us

Container: Insert Find Next Visite

TBinaryTree 0.473 us 1.125 us 0.086 us

THashMap 0.422 us 0.860 us 0.075 us(copy Values to TArrayList,it is not ture test!)

THashSet 0.500 us 0.780 us "Container.First" is O(N*N) is bad,can not test!

ps: THashXXX.Create()

for I := 0 to FCapacity - 1 do

SetLength(FBuckets[I].Entries, 64);) //is bad design, slow and waste memory!

ps: TLinkedList.Clear() ERROR !!!

procedure TLinkedList.Clear;

.....

//ERROR , must add line: FStart:=nil;

end;

================================================================================

DeCal lab (Delphi7 Compile)=====================================================

Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront

DArray 0.272 us 0.170 us 0.321 us 53000.000 us 125000.000 us

DList 0.238 us 0.106 us 13062.000 us 0.198 us 0.188 us

Container: Insert Find Next Visite

DSet 2.125 us 6.422 us 0.091 us

DMultiSet 2.055 us 5.688 us 0.086 us

DMap 1.993 us 4.921 us 0.081 us

DMultiMap 1.930 us 5.422 us 0.120 us

DHashSet 0.946 us 2.406 us 0.974 us

DMultiHashSet 0.836 us 2.407 us 0.977 us

DHashMap 1.164 us 2.266 us 0.987 us

DMultiHashMap 1.063 us 2.172 us 0.922 us

================================================================================

EZDSL lab (Delphi7 Compile)=====================================================

Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront

(TEZCollection is maxsize is N=10922*92 for test! it is small for test.)

TEZCollection 0.078 us 0.077 us 4.667 us 0.388 us 0.588 us

TDList 0.175 us 0.039 us 6250.000 us 0.167 us 0.147 us

TLinkList 0.169 us 0.031 us 13300.000 us 0.180 us 0.159 us

Container: Push Pop

TQueue 0.141 us 0.150 us

TStack 0.144 us 0.147 us

Container: Insert Find Next Visite

THashTable 1.934 us 2.695 us (not find way to test!)

================================================================================

 
免责声明:本文为网络用户发布,其观点仅代表作者个人观点,与本站无关,本站仅提供信息存储服务。文中陈述内容未经本站证实,其真实性、完整性、及时性本站不作任何保证或承诺,请读者仅作参考,并请自行核实相关内容。
 
(Delphi泛型库DGL [url=http://cosoft.org.cn/projects/dgl/]下载[/url]) 几个库DGL、STL(vc6)、STL(SGI)、DCL 、DeCal、EZDSL的容器性能对比测试 (2006.10.20 DGL Profiler DGL添加红黑树,增加容器:_TMap\_TMultiMap\_TSet\_TMultiSet; 更新DeCal和EZDSL的Hash表测试,由于它们不支持动态调整大小所以造成以前的测试成绩不能反映真实情况; 测试Visite或Find的时候会同时测试读和写,如果不能写,就读两次 DGL和STL使用了相同的测试,测试数据集1000万个integer;选用integer能够更好地反映库的性能; (某些Delphi库使用string的测试成绩来说自己的库比STL的快完全是误导,这完全是由string的不同实现导致的); 其他几个库的测试,如果库的性能比较差,就会采取减小测试数据集的办法来减少测试时间; 对于线性容器(vector\deque\list)的随机访问使用了1M个integer; ) CPU: AMD Athlon(tm)64 3000+(1.81G) DGL lib (Delphi7 Compile)======================================================== Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront TVector 0.011 us 0.008 us 0.086 us 31400.000 us 75000.000 us TDeque 0.009 us 0.012 us 0.219 us 100000.000 us 0.009 us TList 0.048 us 0.017 us 8590.000 us 0.077 us 0.055 us IVector 0.018 us 0.018 us 0.110 us 31200.000 us 75000.000 us IDeque 0.014 us 0.019 us 0.235 us 103200.000 us 0.011 us IList 0.073 us 0.022 us 8440.000 us 0.077 us 0.056 us Container: Insert Find Next Visite Map 0.384 us 3.383 us 0.070 us MultiMap 0.388 us 3.706 us 0.097 us Set 0.461 us 3.253 us 0.064 us MultiSet 0.457 us 3.260 us 0.064 us HashMap 0.288 us 0.857 us 0.048 us HashMultiMap 0.296 us 0.961 us 0.067 us HashSet 0.284 us 0.869 us 0.052 us HashMultiSet 0.254 us 0.868 us 0.046 us DGL lib (Turbo Delphi2006 Compile)======================================================== Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront TVector 0.029 us 0.007 us 0.079 us 27600.000 us 66800.000 us TDeque 0.007 us 0.009 us 0.234 us 113200.000 us 0.006 us TList 0.029 us 0.015 us 8520.000 us 0.066 us 0.037 us IVector 0.025 us 0.015 us 0.107 us 33000.000 us 79600.000 us IDeque 0.010 us 0.015 us 0.245 us 103400.000 us 0.013 us IList 0.050 us 0.017 us 8950.000 us 0.054 us 0.034 us Container: Insert Find Next Visite Map 0.370 us 3.592 us 0.075 us MultiMap 0.388 us 3.873 us 0.104 us Set 0.366 us 3.254 us 0.062 us MultiSet 0.345 us 3.275 us 0.062 us HashMap 0.292 us 0.832 us 0.039 us HashMultiMap 0.275 us 0.898 us 0.060 us HashSet 0.248 us 0.847 us 0.043 us HashMultiSet 0.245 us 0.847 us 0.036 us ================================================================================ Delphi7========================================================================= Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront array 0.170 us 0.005 us 0.078 us 43800.000 us 121800.000 us TList 0.023 us 0.013 us 0.125 us 25000.000 us 62400.000 us ================================================================================ STL (VC6 Compile)=============================================================== Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront vector 0.041 us 0.005 us 0.078 us 31200 us 68800 us deque 0.013 us 0.006 us 0.227 us 365600 us 0.012 us list 0.169 us 0.022 us 21800 us 0.180 us 0.183 us Container: Insert Find Next Visite map 0.431 us 3.174 us 0.048 us set 0.433 us 3.174 us 0.049 us multimap 0.430 us 3.174 us 0.047 us multiset 0.427 us 3.174 us 0.048 us STL (VC2005 Compile)=============================================================== vector 0.019 us 0.009 us 0.078 us 62600 us 140600 us deque 0.067 us 0.013 us 0.227 us 168800 us 0.061 us list 0.269 us 0.017 us 15600 us 0.277 us 0.269 us Container: Insert Find Next Visite map 2.436 us 4.813 us 0.042 us set 2.473 us 4.813 us 0.041 us multimap 2.420 us 4.813 us 0.041 us multiset 2.416 us 4.813 us 0.041 us hash_map 0.888 us 1.501 us 0.207 us hash_set 1.378 us 1.453 us 0.207 us hash_multimap 1.373 us 1.450 us 0.207 us hash_multiset 1.380 us 1.450 us 0.207 us (SGI)STL (DEV-C++4.98 GCC max optimize Compile)================================= Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront vector 0.016 us 0.005 us 0.070 us 34400 us 62400 us deque 0.011 us 0.009 us 0.258 us 865600 us 0.013 us list 0.047 us 0.014 us 9400 us 0.052 us 0.036 us Container: Insert Find Next Visite map 0.538 us 3.226 us 0.033 us set 0.516 us 3.226 us 0.034 us multimap 0.492 us 3.174 us 0.038 us multiset 0.495 us 3.994 us 0.039 us hash_map 0.145 us 0.701 us 0.043 us hash_set 0.234 us 0.650 us 0.044 us hash_multimap 0.639 us 0.698 us 0.044 us hash_multiset 0.138 us 0.650 us 0.043 us ================================================================================ DCL lib (Delphi7 Compile)======================================================= Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront TArrayList 0.013 us 0.030 us 0.157 us 25000.000 us 65600.000 us TVector 0.013 us 0.027 us 0.172 us 28200.000 us 62600.000 us TLinkedList 0.045 us 0.023 us 5780.000 us 0.052 us 0.081 us Container: Insert Find Next Visite TBinaryTree 0.473 us 1.125 us 0.086 us THashMap 0.422 us 0.860 us 0.075 us(copy Values to TArrayList,it is not ture test!) THashSet 0.500 us 0.780 us "Container.First" is O(N*N) is bad,can not test! ps: THashXXX.Create() for I := 0 to FCapacity - 1 do SetLength(FBuckets[I].Entries, 64);) //is bad design, slow and waste memory! ps: TLinkedList.Clear() ERROR !!! procedure TLinkedList.Clear; ..... //ERROR , must add line: FStart:=nil; end; ================================================================================ DeCal lab (Delphi7 Compile)===================================================== Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront DArray 0.272 us 0.170 us 0.321 us 53000.000 us 125000.000 us DList 0.238 us 0.106 us 13062.000 us 0.198 us 0.188 us Container: Insert Find Next Visite DSet 2.125 us 6.422 us 0.091 us DMultiSet 2.055 us 5.688 us 0.086 us DMap 1.993 us 4.921 us 0.081 us DMultiMap 1.930 us 5.422 us 0.120 us DHashSet 0.946 us 2.406 us 0.974 us DMultiHashSet 0.836 us 2.407 us 0.977 us DHashMap 1.164 us 2.266 us 0.987 us DMultiHashMap 1.063 us 2.172 us 0.922 us ================================================================================ EZDSL lab (Delphi7 Compile)===================================================== Container: PushBack Next Visite Random Visite Insert At Middle PushFront (TEZCollection is maxsize is N=10922*92 for test! it is small for test.) TEZCollection 0.078 us 0.077 us 4.667 us 0.388 us 0.588 us TDList 0.175 us 0.039 us 6250.000 us 0.167 us 0.147 us TLinkList 0.169 us 0.031 us 13300.000 us 0.180 us 0.159 us Container: Push Pop TQueue 0.141 us 0.150 us TStack 0.144 us 0.147 us Container: Insert Find Next Visite THashTable 1.934 us 2.695 us (not find way to test!) ================================================================================
󰈣󰈤
 
 
 
>>返回首页<<
 
 热帖排行
 
 
静静地坐在废墟上,四周的荒凉一望无际,忽然觉得,凄凉也很美
©2005- 王朝网络 版权所有